Before you drop the price, check the other two Ps

A puzzled homeowner raises his hands outside a Queensland-style home with a generic For Sale sign.

Illustration; not an actual property listing.

The property is online. The photographs are up. The first open home has come and gone. Yet the offers everyone expected haven’t arrived.

Usually, someone says it: “Perhaps we need to drop the price.”

Sometimes that is the right conversation. But Edgar Natolo wants to understand what is happening before deciding which number to change.

“For me, it’s always the three Ps,” he says. Presentation, promotion and price. “The price gets affected by the first two.”

The three belong in the same conversation. A home can be beautifully presented but poorly explained online. An advertisement can attract attention, then disappoint people at the front door. And even when both are working, the asking price can sit beyond what buyers will consider.

The useful question is where people are stopping, and why.

Presentation: buyers see the jobs ahead

An owner knows the house. They may have stopped noticing the yellowed switch covers, scratched flooring or cupboard that needs attention. A buyer is seeing those things together for the first time.

Their calculation can go well beyond the price of a tin of paint or new carpet. Someone has to find the trades, arrange access, make decisions and manage the work. An experienced renovator might welcome that project. A buyer who wants to move in and get on with life may see months of inconvenience.

Edgar described a former rental that showed how a collection of smaller jobs could change that impression. It had been rented for years. The walls were a creamy yellow, fittings had yellowed and older floating floorboards were scratched and dated.

The refresh went beyond a coat of paint. Walls were repainted, fresh carpet went down and modern white fans replaced older fittings. An oversized intercom was removed. Grout, silicone and water damage around vanities received attention, and door handles were updated.

The garage mattered too: tired cupboards came out, cracks and joints were repaired and the patchy concrete floor was painted. Outside, tiles, grout, the concrete fence, poolside timber deck and pontoon also needed work.

Beforehand, a buyer could walk through and mentally assemble a list of painters, plasterers, flooring installers, electricians and tilers. Afterwards, there was less work standing between them and the idea of living there.

“It’s not really that big a cost compared to the impression that it now gives,” Edgar says.

That is a reason to choose the work carefully, rather than renovate everything. The property, likely buyer and cost still matter. The lesson is about removing the concerns a buyer notices before they can appreciate the home.

Promotion: show why someone would live there

Once the home is ready, the advertising has to help the right people understand it.

Dark photographs, awkward angles and missing rooms can make a good property difficult to assess. Without a floorplan or measurements, buyers may struggle to work out whether their furniture, family or daily routine will fit.

Then there is the description. Bedrooms, bathrooms and parking tell people what is included. They do not necessarily explain why this particular house might feel right.

“The features are one thing,” Edgar says. “But the feeling of living in the area or that street or that house, that’s what you’re really selling.”

That feeling needs to come from real details: how the rooms connect, what the outdoor space offers and what everyday life in the home and its surroundings could look like. The inspection should confirm the advertising, rather than reveal the things it avoided showing.

Edgar also looks beyond the advertisement itself. Photography, video, drone footage, brochures, social advertising and direct contact with suitable database buyers can all have a role. The choice should follow the property and audience. A bigger marketing bill does not, by itself, show that the right buyers are being reached or followed up.

Price: being listed is only the beginning

Presentation and promotion do not remove the market’s limits. Buyers compare the home with competing listings, recent sales and what they can afford.

Edgar uses a simple example: if relevant buyers are looking between $750,000 and $800,000, asking $850,000 to $900,000 may put a property outside their search. Those figures illustrate positioning; they are not a valuation of a particular home.

A seller can be “on the market” without being “in the market”—available for sale, but outside the range where the active buyers are prepared to engage.

“No buyers coming through is feedback,” he says.

Read what happens next

The campaign’s different stages help locate the problem.

Few listing views? Examine visibility, the lead photograph, headline and price positioning. Plenty of views but few enquiries? Look at how the home compares and whether the advertisement leaves important questions unanswered.

Enquiries without inspections call for a closer look at the conversations. What are people asking? Are arrangements practical? Are calls and emails being followed up promptly?

Inspections without offers need a different discussion. Does the home feel smaller than the photographs suggested? Is maintenance more noticeable in person? Are people repeatedly raising the same garden, wall colour, layout or noise concern?

“As soon as you get two or three of the same responses, fix it,” Edgar says of recurring practical issues.

One comment can be personal taste. A repeated concern deserves investigation. Some things can be repaired or improved; others are features buyers will weigh against the price.

If several serious buyers arrive at similar offers below expectations, that pattern also needs explaining. One low offer does not settle the question, but neither should consistent evidence be brushed aside.

Edgar’s approach is to keep reviewing the campaign, with a deliberate reassessment at least every fortnight. The owner should understand what the agent has learned, what change is recommended and what that change is meant to achieve.

Before changing the price, check the other two Ps. Then be willing to have the price conversation if the evidence points there. The aim is to address the obstacle, rather than leave everything unchanged and hope next weekend feels different.

Leave a Reply